Adam Wakefield peers into the past, present, and future of online publishing, and the value of the subscription model.
Subscriptions are worth more than online advertising
Prior to the Internet, publishers pursued a mixed model of subscriptions, single sale copies, and placed advertising. However, as noted by content recommendation platform Bibblio on Medium
, newspaper publishers broke from this mixed revenue model and relied exclusively on advertising for “their own survival”. Bibblio called the decision to move away from that mixed revenue module a “moment of madness”.
However, the increasing dominance of Google and Facebook within the online advertising space has seen publishers competing for a shrinking piece of pie. According to eMarketer’s 2017 report
, titled Beyond the Duopoly: Exploring Digital Advertising Outside Google and Facebook
, the two companies will control 63% of all online ad spend in the United States in 2018. In the United Kingdom, Google and Facebook accounted for 54% of the digital advertising market
According to Frederic Filloux, editor of the Monday Note
, the New York Times has shown the difference subscribers can make on average revenue per user (ARPU).The New York Times’
ARPU, based on paying subscribers, is USD 140. This is compared to Buzzfeed’s
ARPU of USD 1, which relies on an unpaid model and advertising. The New York Times’
advertising ARPU is only USD 3, while Facebook’s and Google’s are USD 62 and USD 77 respectively.
Put another way, the revenue produced by The New York Times’
digital subscribers is 46 times higher than the publications advertising revenue, spread across its entire audience.
“While precise figures have yet to emerge, many news organisations that rely on subscriptions feel the same trend. From Brexit to Trump, the rise of populism favours a flight to quality information,” Filloux says.
Viewed from a branding perspective, as noted by WE Communications’ president of international and WE+, Alan VanderMolen when speaking about the firm’s Brands in Motion study, brands can provide stability in uncertain times
. This is a niche news organisations can fill.
Online subscriptions offer publishers revenue and subscribers value
Any consumer purchase has a value proposition
decision at its heart. The consumers online publishers aim to reach are no exception.
According to Henriëtte Loubser, editor of Afrikaans news portal Netwerk24
, readers who are willing to pay for their content understand that it is the same content they have paid for in print for decades. They know that original “on the ground” reporting is expensive, and cannot be funded by advertising alone.
is rooted in its market. The journalists who previously produced copy for Die Burger
, and Volksblad
have all moved to Netwerk24
and now produce copy digitally first,” Loubser says.
“The print newspapers then select from this copy for every day’s print editions. This means that the editors and journalists working on Netwerk24
are part of a proud heritage of serving the Afrikaans market, in the case of Volksblad
and Die Burger
, for more than a century already.”
Readers know that the journalistic principles that guided the print publications to produce first-hand, quality, in-depth reporting remain in place with the digital product.
“This is why Media24’s newspapers have always had cover prices, and why it is still needed in the digital era,” she says.
“This is even more true because of digital advertising income not yet equalling print advertising levels and, in the case of Afrikaans, the online advertising market being a drop in the ocean compared to the English market.”
Readers are therefore helping Netwerk24
build a “future for original Afrikaans journalism”. Loubser also cited the success of The New York Times, and Washington Post, among other platforms in the English-speaking world, as examples of how a subscription model can succeed.
By the end of December 2017, Netwerk24
had 28 535 subscribers. Subscriptions grew by 15% in November and 6% in December.
Lisa MacLoed, head of digital at Tiso Blackstar Group, home of BusinessLive
, which uses a hybrid freemium subscription model, says BusinessLIVE's
pricing has been set according to reader research. High-quality premium local and international content is available for paying subscribers, while a 'steady stream' of content is provided for those who cannot pay.
is a freemium model, and is still 80% free, with only 20% paid-for content, providing up to 200 stories a day. Access is free for print subscribers. We also provide discounts for pensioners, and we’re looking at alternative models to reach the student market,” MacLeod says.
"We recently launched the BusinessLIVE paywall and, to date, have more than 10 000 paid-for active subscribers. The new digital-only subscribers represent a more than 20% uplift in our total business subscriber base.”
If online publishers offer readers value for money, they will become subscribers
As important as it is to attract new subscribers, retaining existing customers is also critical in maintaining a predictable revenue stream.
Loubser says Netwerk24’s
paywall was introduced after Media24’s decision to consolidate their individual Afrikaans print titles’ websites into Netwerk24
. Initially, it functioned as a metered paywall, with 10 articles available for readers to read for free a month.
It later evolved into a solid paywall in June 2016, where subscribers have 30 days all-access, and then had to choose either the digital-only option or digital plus, which includes physical home delivery of a Saturday edition of the newspaper of their choice. Full week subscribers to Beeld
, Die Burger
have all-access to Netwerk24
. Magazines were added to the Netwerk24
bouquet in November, giving readers extra incentive to subscribe.
Loubser says subscribers must be given a unique offering, which is value for money that they cannot get elsewhere.
“This certainly is the case with Netwerk24
housing the daily newspapers, Rapport
, 11 magazines, and more than 30 community newspapers all in one place, whilst also providing users with fresh breaking news and analysis as it happens 18 hours per day, 7 days per week,” Loubser explains.
Want to stay up to date with the latest media news? Subscribe to our newsletter.
Image courtesy of Sollok29, under this license.