Traditional media in the social media revolution

Broadcast and print media have traditionally been known as dominant sources for news, mostly due to their perceived credibility. A new element comes into play with the growth of the Internet surpassing that of television (Sagan & Leighto, 2010:119). It has been found that 24% of South Africans are active social media users, where the average time spent on social media is 2 hours 43 minutes daily1. As a result of this exponential increase, the consumption of news today has evolved exceedingly. Although television, newspaper, and radio are still relevant, social media is changing the way we consume news. The 2016 Global Ogilvy Media Influence Survey showed the growing importance of new platforms where consumers are increasingly reading news on mobile applications and social media platforms2. In a second study, by the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism (RISJ), it was found that, across 26 countries, 51% of the sample use social media as a news source (Newman, Fletcher Levy & Nielsen, 2016:8).

Before social media, the audience played a bystander role in news consumption, however, a new world has opened up, allowing personalisation and participation (Saffo, 2005). People are able to assist in capturing, writing, and sharing news over social media platforms, allowing the reader to take control, challenging the traditional concept of ‘one-way news’ (Sagan & Leighto, 2010:119). It has been suggested that “people use online social tools to gather information, share stories, and discuss concerns” (Fox, 2011:5). Unique to the Internet, its pervasiveness and accessibility introduces an immediacy of information which accelerates the pace of news (Sagan & Leighto, 2010:119). The growth of the Internet is undeniable, showing no signs of slowing down. This raises concerns for journalists and traditional forms of media to provide audiences with the news that they want, when and how they want it3. 


The transformation of social media

Through the rise of social media, “we are witnessing the emergence of powerful new voices and networks which can act independently of the traditional media. Highly networked individuals (helped by new platforms like social networking and messaging) can move across, undermine, and go beyond the boundaries of existing institutions,” (Newman, 2009). A recent survey, conducted by Pew Research Centre, indicated that 62% of adults in the USA receive news on social media and 18% do so often (Gottfried & Shearer, 2016:2). With the USA as an influential first-world country, the study illustrates what South Africa can expect in future. The evident media shift presents the news industry with opportunities and challenges, where social media has become a significant communication and news-breaking tool (Alejandro, 2010:10). What many media academics and practitioners are calling a ‘crisis in journalism,’ has resulted in changing practices in many related industries (Macnamara, 2014:2). Journalists leverage these social platforms as news aggregators to assist with their work in an attempt to stay ahead with audience demands (Alejandro, 2010:42; Sagan & Leighto, 2010:119). “Social media has gone from being a channel that distributes the news, to one that informs it, with 50% of surveyed journalists saying that they use social media as a source for the stories they will cover2.” With the news industry transforming, journalists are presented with an opportunity to respond to social, cultural, and technological changes (Alejandro, 2010:42). A Social Sensor research project found that the top 5 functions of social media for journalists were: [1] predicting or alerting breaking news; [2] verifying social media content; [3] listening/following high quality profiles to identify relevant stories; [4] tracking trends; and [5] easily distributing content (Schifferes, Newman, Thurman, Corney, Göker, & Martin, 2014:5). 

Social media is not without its faults, as many question the reliability of information and accredit poor quality to the growing ‘cult of the amateur’ (Keen, 2007). Social media is renowned for its speed and relevance, but not necessarily for its accuracy3. It has been said that via social media, misinformation is spread as facts become lost in the shuffle of competing information, limited attention, or both4. It was found that the main reason for individuals not using social media as a source for news lies in the lack of credibility of articles, as many are not written by qualified journalists or reviewed by a reputable authority (Behesht-Kashi & Makki, 2013:100-104). The role of traditional media remains relevant due to the accompanied perception of credibility3. It was highlighted in the 2016 Global Ogilvy Media Influence Survey that traditional media channels are the most trusted and that credibility is attributed to the media outlet. “People still want value and identify with traditional news brands5.” It can be deduced that this perception is owing to reputations built over time, as the original source of an article on social media is often unknown (Newman, et al., 2016:9). “Stories covered in traditional media outlets [are] seen as more influential, underlining the importance of traditional media relations for making brands matter2.”

Concluding remarks

It has been argued that the traditional news industry is ‘rapidly losing control,’ resulting from the impact of social media6. Juan Senor, partner at Innovation Media, argues traditional media will continue to prevail: “No medium has ever replaced another medium. It [has] not happened and it’s never going to happen7.” He further comments that in order to remain competitive, a ‘mediamorphosis’ is inevitable to adapt to the thriving digital age8. This process of change within the news industry is still underway, and could result in output moving increasingly, if not exclusively, towards digital platforms (Schlesinger & Doyle, 2014:12). It can be deduced that the increase in use of social media creates opportunities for traditional news platforms.

Social media sites aim to connect people and is evidently fulfilling this aim. The platform is provided for users to collaborate and work together to create and distribute content (O’Reilly & Battelle, 2009). Media organisations no longer have a monopoly on journalism, resulting in changing power structures and competition (Alejandro, 2010:12). All media platforms act as a megaphone for individuals, organisations, and traditional media (Macnamara, 2014:2), with social media becoming “a public space for coordination, mobilisation, education, charity fundraising and doing business as well” (Alejandro, 2010:41). 

It is clear that the way people consume news has transformed due to the changing media landscape, the new role of the user, and the shift in power dynamics within the industry (Sagan & Leighto, 2010:119). The growing role of social media as a news platform, as well as its referral to mass media, indicates the increasing interconnectedness and interrelatedness of the platforms (Macnamara, 2014:7). Social media inevitably challenges traditional news platforms. It should, however, not be viewed as a threat to the industry, but rather seen as a complementary platform aiding journalists and providing users with different viewpoints.

To download the analysis as a PDF, click here.

*Focal Points uses both qualitative and quantitative methods to investigate topics of interest in the media and provides academic insights. Focal Points sources its research data from Newsclip Media Monitoring.  

About Newsclip

Newsclip has over 30 years’ experience in media monitoring and content management, providing clients with meaningful and measurable media solutions. Newsclip monitors the full media landscape in South Africa, along with an expanding African portfolio. 

For more information, visit www.newsclip.co.za. Alternatively, connect with them on Facebook, Twitter or on LinkedIn.

References

Alejandro, J. 2010. Journalism in the age of social media. Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, 42.
Behesht-Kashi, S. & Makki, B. 2013. Social Media News: Motivation, purpose and usage. International Journal of Computer Science & Information Technology, 5(2): 97-105.
Fox, S. 2011. The social life of health information. Pew Research Center’s Internet & American Life Project, (December).
Gottfried, J. & Shearer, E. 2016. News use across social media platforms. Pew Research Center, (2016):1-19.
Keen, Andrew. 2007. The Cult of the Amateur: How Today's Internet is Killing Our Culture. London: Broadway Business.
Macnamara, J. 2014. Which media set the news agenda: Mass media or/and social media? iSentia. Available from: http://www.isentia.com/assets/blog/special/isentia_whitepaper_layout_international_d1.pdf. [Downloaded on: 07/07/2016].
Newman, N., Fletcher, R., Levy, D. & Nielsen, R. 2016. Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2016. Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism. (2016):1-124.
Newman, N. 2009. “The rise of social media and its impact on mainstream journalism”, Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, Working Paper September.
O’Reilly, T., & Battelle, J. 2009. Web squared: Web 2.0 Five years on. O’Reilly Media, Inc. Available from: http://assets.en.oreilly.com/1/event/28/web2009_websquared-whitepaper.pdf. [Downloaded on: 07/07/2016].
P. Saffo. 2005. Farewell Information, it’s a Media Age. (December).
Sagan, Paul, and Tom Leighton. 2010. The Internet & the future of news. American Academy of Arts & Sciences, 139(2): 119-125.
Schifferes, S., Newman, N., Thurman, N., Corney, D., Goker, A.S. & Martin, C. 2014. Identifying and verifying news through social media: Developing a user-centred tool for professional journalists. Digital Journalism, 2(3): 406-418.
Schlesinger, P. & Doyle, G. 2014. From organizational crisis to multi-platform salvation? Creative destruction and the recomposition of news media. Journalism: Theory, Practice and Criticism. May: 1-12.

1We Are Social. http://www.slideshare.net/wearesocialsg/digital-in-2016/2-earesocialsg_2. Published on: 26/01/2016.
2PR Newswire. http://news.sys-con.com/node/3887408. Published on: 03/08/2016.
3Jim Egan. http://www.themarketingsite.com/news/43355/the-transformation-of-news. Published on: 19/04/2016.
4Gugu Louri. http://techfinancials.co.za/2016/07/how-social-media-can-distort-and-misinform-when-communicating-science/. Published on: 01/07/2016.
5Deutsche Welle. http://www.dailynewsegypt.com/2016/06/16/news-consumption-in-a-digital-world/. Published on: 16/07/2016.
6The Guardian. http://guardian.ng/features/media-firms-lose-control-of-news-as-tech-platforms-rise/. Published on: 29/06/2016.
7Adam Wakefield. http://www.mediaupdate.co.za/media/112729/future-of-media-conference-newspapers-must-undergo-mediamorphosis-to-thrive-in-the-digital-age-part-1. Published on: 25/07/2016.
8Adam Wakefield. http://www.mediaupdate.co.za/media/112730/future-of-media-conference-newspapers-must-undergo-mediamorphosis-to-thrive-in-digital-age-part-2. Published on: 25/07/2016.